Whimsy Soul
  • Subscribe 📧
  • Book My Cabin
    • Book Now
    • Shop The Cabin
  • Reviews
  • Fashion
  • Travel
  • Witch
  • Lifestyle
    • Home Decor
    • Beauty
    • Wellness
  • About
    • About Whimsy Soul
    • Meet The Team
    • Press
    • Work With Us
  • Contact
  • About
  • Contact
  • Work With Us
  • Meet The Team
  • Our Cabin
  • Subscribe ⭐️
Whimsy Soul
Whimsy Soul
  • Reviews
  • Travel
    • Hotels
    • California
    • Europe
    • United States
    • West Coast
    • Southwest
    • Midwest
    • East Coast
    • Latin America
    • Canada
  • Fashion
  • Witchy
  • Lifestyle
    • Beauty
    • Reviews
    • Wellness
    • Witchy Things
    • Home Decor
Home Fashion Vivaia Shoes Review After A Year Of Wear (Spoiler Alert, I Love This Shoe Brand)
  • Fashion
  • Reviews
  • Saw It On Social - Honest Product & Brand Reviews

Vivaia Shoes Review After A Year Of Wear (Spoiler Alert, I Love This Shoe Brand)

  • Kara
  • November 9, 2023
  • Contains Affiliate Links

As a 30-something my priority of shoes has shifted from my 20’s. While getting ready for frat parties in college, we would throw on ridiculously tipsy heels that hurt after walking 2 blocks (but looked FANTASTIC). 

These days, I’m hyper focused on comfort, but I also still want fantastic-looking shoes. I just don’t want to break my ankles wearing them. 

Enter: my hunt for chic yet comfy shoes (bonus points if they’re made by a company with ethical or sustainable values). Which is how I discovered Vivaia. I ordered a few pairs and spent a few weeks testing them out for my honest Vivaia Shoes review to see if they really live up to the type. 

This Vivaia shoe review is part of our Saw It On Social series, where we review the brands you see all over your feed and spill the real tea on if they are worth it or not. 

For this review, I bought the Samantha Square-Toe Loafers and the Madaline Over-Knee Water Repellent Wool Boots. 

Vivaia Shoes Are Sustainable And Fashion Forward

Vivaia is a new sustainable shoe brand that makes their shoes out of recycled plastic bottles! They founded in 2020 and are already taking the shoe world by storm.

All of their shoes are also machine washable to rival brands like Rothys but also makes caring for shoes easier for gals like me who are constantly getting my footwear dirty. Hey, I like to travel and that means my shoes get dirty! 

I’ve been wearing Rothy flats for years but wanted to try something new with a square toe vs a pointed toe. I also have been itching to upgrade my tall boots and loafers. Vivaia Shoes has not just flats, but heels, loafers, boots and extra tall boots, the latter I bought. 

My Vivaia Shoes Review After Wearing For An Entire Year

Over-the-Knee Boots (Madeline)
Over-the-Knee Boots (Madeline)
4.5

The Madeline boot features a soft terry lining to keep your legs warm, cozy and comfortable throughout your entire day, and a stretch shaft! They are a statement boot that comes in many neutral colors and are water-resistant, too. This is my favorite boot of the season.

Pros:
  • water resistant
  • Anti-stain
  • Antimicrobial and Breathable
  • very comfy
  • soft lining
  • calf portion stays up all day
Cons:
  • not machine washable
  • calves run tight (like a compression sock)
Buy Now

Madaline Over-Knee Water Repellent Wool Boots Review

Spoiler alert: these are the shoes I kept from my order. I’ve been itching for a new pair of over the knee boots and loved the look and feel of Vivaia tall boots online. 

Like all over the knee boots, they’re hard to put on. It’s like wrestling a cat into a costume, there’s just no easy way around it. But once I have them one, they feel free great. 

The calves on the Madaline Boots could be a little roomier but I love styling these boots with the tops folded down and the arch support is very comfy. Though, they just launched a new Pro arch support model of the boot which I bet is even better (but I’ve worn my pair all day and with many miles logged and my feet don’t hurt). 

The fabric is water repellent which does not mean waterproof. Don’t go stepping in a giant puddle an expect dry feet, but it’s great for situations like a rainy day or walking on dewy grass in the morning. 

I style these boots with dresses and skirts, and they quickly have become a staple in my fall wardrobe. They come in a lot of earth ton colors and I’m eyeing their black boots to really round out my closet. 

The only downside is the boots aren’t machine washable. 

Square-Toe Loafers Review

Samantha Square-Toe Loafers
Samantha Square-Toe Loafers
4.0

Surround your feet with coziness, comfort, and style. Samantha is wide feet friendly, and features a hyper stretchy knit upper. Arch support footbed to keep your foot comfort, combined with a long-lasting carbon-free rubber outsole. Perfect to wear indoors and outdoors.

Pros:
  • Made from 6 Plastic Bottles
  • Machine washable
  • Antimicrobial and Breathable
  • PU foam insole
Cons:
  • Runs small
  • Could use more color options
Buy Now

I really wanted to love these loafers, I really did. But the sizing was all wrong on them. I got my trusty size 9 but they were way to small. A size 10 would have fit better since the toe box was a little small. 

I could have exchanged them but decided just to return them. That being said, I tried them on and if you remove the tight fit, I could tell the Vivaia Loafers are very high quality. 

The most notable part is how it feels like you are walking on a cloud since the inside is so squishy! I could see how these are great for travelers or people on their feet all day who need good arch support. 

I do wish I bought one of the Vivaia collection heels, just to test. I saw Selena Gomez wearing a pair of their block heels and if she approves, I think I would too. I’m not a big heel wearer these days, but I just may buy a pair and update this post if I do. 

What You Need To Know About Vivaia Shoes Before You Order

Vivaia Shoes Sizing Runs Small

Vivaia sizing was a little less than desirable for me. I found their shoes run small, so with that in mind please size up or buy a couple pairs and pick the best fit. 

I bought the loafers in my usual size 9 but they were WAY too small. I think a 10 would have been better. 

That being said, they do offer wide sizes on most shoes, in case your feet run large. I wish they offered shoes for gals with wide calves, though. I love my over the knee boots, but the calf portion squeezes my legs. It feels like a compression sock which isn’t bad but a little extra room would be nice. 

Where To Buy Vivaia Shoes

It’s best to buy them directly from the company, as they frequently have sales happening, free shipping offers and other deals. But you can also find them on Amazon. 

Vivaia Shoe Reviews Complaints

Vivaia is NOT BBB accredited (Better Business Bureau). It seems like most negative Vivaia Shoes reviews revolve around return processes, so just make sure you understand return policies when you order. Again. I had no issues and I thought they were clear. 

 

Vivaia Returns Are Pretty Easy

On that note, let’s chat returns!

The biggest pressure test I like to put on brands are their return policy and return process. Some brands make it really easy – they include a pre-printed return label to make it easy to pop in the mail. 

For my Vivaia Flats that didn’t make the cut for me, I did have to print out my return label but returns are free and otherwise pretty easy. 

I also got my refund within a week so no complaints there. Longer than with Amazon shopping but very fast. They pride themselves on a 30~45 Day Return & Exchange Policy which is great. 

If you were looking to shop Vivaia again, during returns they offer you to swap the shoe for store credit that’s worth more than the shoe value, which is just something to keep in mind. 

Vivaia Shoes Reviews – Final Verdict

So, is Vivaia Shoes worth it? Yes! If you couldn’t tell from my Vivaia review, I do like this company and I do plan on ordering from them again in the future. 

My biggest hang up is the sizing, as they seem to run very small. But the materials are breathable, comfy and sustainable. They make beautiful styles of shoes, boots and flats and I love how they are machine washable. 

I also really love their focus on extra arch support for us folks looking for a little help on the feet. They make great travel shoes since they are so comfy and washable. I myself wore my boots to Mendocino while glamping, got them dirty and was able to rinse them off easily. 

I want to grab a pair of their Margot mary janes next since they look dang cute and like they could rival Rothys well. 

 
Over-the-Knee Boots (Madeline)
 
Square-Toe Chunky Heels (Melody Pro)
 
Samantha Square-Toe Loafers
Over-the-Knee Boots (Madeline)
Square-Toe Chunky Heels (Melody Pro)
Square-Toe Loafers (Samantha)
Primary Rating:
4.5
Primary Rating:
4.5
Primary Rating:
4.0
Buy Now
Buy Now
Buy Now
Over-the-Knee Boots (Madeline)
Over-the-Knee Boots (Madeline)
Primary Rating:
4.5
Buy Now
Square-Toe Chunky Heels (Melody Pro)
Square-Toe Chunky Heels (Melody Pro)
Primary Rating:
4.5
Buy Now
Samantha Square-Toe Loafers
Square-Toe Loafers (Samantha)
Primary Rating:
4.0
Buy Now

Frequently Asked Questions About Vivaia Shoes

Are Vivaia shoes comfortable?

When you get them in the right size and style, yes! As I chatted about before, I had a little issues with the sizing but once I nailed it, I found them to be more comfortable than my Rothys. 

I haven’t tried their heels yet, but they even have something called the “pro” shoe, a new feature after a lot of comments from users wanting even MORE cushion and arch support on their feet. For example, the Melody Pro – Upgraded Pressure Relief Insoles has even more comfort built in so you can wear the items all day long. 

How is Vivaia shoes customer service?

Great I had a question about my order and I heard from the team via email within 48 hours. 

Is Vivaia Sustainable?

Maybe? Good On You rates them right in the middle with a “it’s a start” since there are still parts of the manufacturing process that is not shared to the public. But the use of recycled materials like recycled water bottles to make product is a great step towards reusing and reducing. 

They also have a goal of becoming a 100% carbon-neutral brand in the future and they claim to have a production process that reduces waste by 30% compared to before. 

Vivaia Shoes Review For Travel

I didn’t just take this recycled shoe brand for walks around my neigbhord, I packed these shoes on trips to test out how they travel. I’m happy to share these are absolutely travel-friendly footwear. 

Winter travel is some of my favorite, so I packed my vivaia madaline high knee boots with me to wine tasting trips, to Europe, even to rugges coastal towns here in California and they have always served me well. 

They did take a while to break in, but once I broke them in I can wear these as walking shoes with all-day comfort while traveling. 

Is Vivaia Shoes High Quality?

I think so! You can tell they are made well and they feel luxurious with high quality knit fabric. Not at all like some other cheap loafers or boots I’ve bought off Amazon or Old Navy. These shoes are built to last years and are worth the price tag.

What is the Vivaia shoes country of origin?

Like most fashion brands, Vivaia manufacturing is based out of China. It is founded by Marina Chen.

Are Vivaia Shoes legit?

Yes! Vivaia shoes are legit and pretty dang nice. They fit well (once you get the right size), are water resistant, wash easily and are comfy for all day walking. 

You can feel confident shopping from here. I guess the only question to ask now is: are you team loafer or flats? What are you going to buy first? 

Kara

I'm the founder of Whimsy Soul (this blog you're reading!) I'm a type 3 enneagram cat lady who lives in San Francisco and loves to find everyday magic to share with others. You can probably find me hunting down hot springs with girlfriends, kayaking, cooking with my husband, petting strangers' dogs or watching like, all the things on Netflix. Follow me on Instagram for even more inspiration!

Previous Article
  • Fashion
  • Reviews
  • Saw It On Social - Honest Product & Brand Reviews
  • Whimsy Writer

Quince Cashmere: How These Affordable Cashmere Sweaters Fit On 3 Different Body Types 

  • Taylor
  • November 8, 2023
  • Sponsored By Quince
  • Contains Affiliate Links
View Post
Next Article
  • Home Decor
  • Reviews
  • Whimsy Homes

Flooret Review: The Easiest Luxury Vinyl Planks For Your Home (That Look Super Pretty, Too)

  • Kara
  • November 12, 2023
  • Contains Affiliate Links
View Post
8 comments
  1. Megan says:
    January 21, 2024 at 5:21 am

    Hi Kara. I was searching for a review and came across your website. Just wanted to say thanks. You were very helpful. I’m a fan now . Megan 😊

    Reply
  2. fnaf plus says:
    March 31, 2024 at 11:45 pm

    I’m here to say thanks. Your post provide much info to me.

    Reply
  3. Jenny says:
    May 4, 2024 at 8:16 pm

    You’re not a model. Quit trying to look like one. The open mouth pose looks ridiculous. The boots you had such a hard time trying to put on is because your cows are too large.

    Reply
    1. Anna says:
      May 16, 2024 at 2:07 pm

      Wow your life must really be awful to take time out of your day to make such bitchy comments. I feel sad for you. I hope you find joy in your life. By the way #spellcheck

      Whimsy soul – I appreciate the excellent review on these shoes!

      Reply
  4. Donna says:
    May 8, 2024 at 12:43 am

    Hi hanks for review about via Lisa shoes . I was wondering about them abut now will take plunge to buys a pair. Thanks for sizing tips. Cheers

    Reply
  5. Kristine Claremont says:
    May 18, 2024 at 5:39 am

    Hi thank you for review. I bought a pair of black pointed toe flats and agree these are superb shoes both stylish and comfortable. I just ordered two more pairs. I wear a size 8, and the flats in size 8 fit me well. If I had gone up to a 9, the flats would have been too large. Just want to mention for other first-time buyers.

    Reply
  6. Serena says:
    April 19, 2025 at 7:16 pm

    Thanks for the honest review. I tried the Madeline boots too and love how comfy they are for all-day wear. Sizing up was key, as mentioned. The water repellent feature saved me in light rain. Ended up keeping mine despite the snug calves. Excited to try their Mary Janes next for more sustainable style.

    Reply
  7. Mireya onfiya says:
    May 5, 2025 at 10:59 pm

    my ex-boyfriend dumped me 7 months ago after I caught him of having an affair with someone else and insulting him. I want him back in my life but he refuse to have any contact with me. I was so confuse and don’t know what to do, so I visited the INTERNET for help and I saw a testimony on how a spell caster help them to get their ex back so I contact the spell caster and explain my problems to him….. he cast a spell for me and assure me of 15 hours that my ex will return to me and to my greatest surprise the third day my peter came knocking on my door and beg for forgiveness. I am so happy that my love is back again and not only that, we are about to get married. Once again thank you Dr Okosun , you are truly talented and gifted contact him on WhatsApp +2348054338132 Okosunspelltemple33@gmail.com

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending Posts
  • 34 Best Restaurants In Copenhagen: Top Nordic, Cheap Eats, Bars, Bakeries & More
    • 16 Texas Glamping Spots: Best Luxury Tents, Stylish Yurts & Treehouses
      • How to Make & Use Moon Water: 24 Ways To Manifest Throughout The Year
        About
        Whimsy Soul is a lifestyle website founded by Kara Harms. Together with a team of talented Whimsy Writers, we inspire our community to take the ordinary and make it extra.
        Learn More
        Follow Whimsy Soul
        Brand
        • About
          • About Us
          • Meet The Team
          • Press
          • Work With Whimsy Soul
        • Contact
          • Contact
        • Kara’s LTK Shop
        • Careers
          • Guest Contribute
          • Open Job Positions
        Travel
        • Destinations
          • United States
          • Wine Regions
          • Latin America
          • Europe
        • City Guides
        • Hotels
        • Whimsy Homes Cabin
        Lifestyle
        • Fashion
        • Beauty
        • Lifestyle
        • Reviews
        Whimsy Soul
        • About
        • Policies
        • Contact
        Find your everyday magic

        Input your search keywords and press Enter.